Subscribe right here: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Overcast | Pocket Casts
Up to date at 3:20 p.m. ET on Might 22, 2025
Expressing concern can typically be a fragile endeavor. One can intend to be empathetic, however the goal of concern hears solely condescension and pity. So it’s with Well being Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who lately talked about how a lot autistic kids endure. These poor children, he mentioned at an April 16 press convention, would by no means “pay taxes. They’ll by no means maintain a job. They’ll by no means play baseball. They’ll by no means write a poem. They’ll by no means exit on a date. A lot of them won’t ever use the bathroom unassisted.” Listening to Kennedy, some dad and mom of autistic kids felt seen. “I discovered myself nodding alongside as Mr. Kennedy spoke concerning the grim realities of profound autism,” Emily Might, whose daughter has restricted verbal potential, wrote in The New York Occasions. However our visitor this week, Eric Garcia, who attended the press convention, noticed it in another way. Such an intimate and detailed accounting of their failures, Garcia says, “virtually bordered on pornography to me.”
Garcia, the creator of We’re Not Damaged: Altering the Autism Dialog and a political reporter on the Unbiased, has watched as Kennedy’s forceful entry into the autism debate has deepened confusion concerning the situation and opened up rifts within the autism neighborhood. On this episode of Radio Atlantic, we discuss with Garcia about myths spreading about autism below Kennedy. Sure, there’s the one about how vaccines trigger autism, which the scientific neighborhood has rejected. However there’s additionally a extra basic one which Kennedy references usually: Is there, as he repeats, an “autism epidemic”? And if not, what explains the dramatic rise in reported instances of autism over the previous few a long time? Garcia additionally recounts his personal story rising up autistic within the age of exploding diagnoses, and touchdown now in a second the place, for his job, he covers a well being secretary’s explicit model of concern.
The next is a transcript of the episode:
Hanna Rosin: Robert F. Kennedy Jr. may be very involved about autism. He has been for a few a long time, since he first grew to become satisfied that mercury in vaccines made kids autistic, which by the way in which, there is no such thing as a credible proof supporting this concept.
On April 16, now as head of Well being and Human Providers, RFK gave a press convention, and he described the tragedy of what he calls the autism “epidemic.”
For years, he has insisted there may be an epidemic, though there may be loads of debate amongst researchers about this—all of which he dismisses as “epidemic denial,” a time period he repeated a number of occasions in that press convention.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: There are a lot of, many different research that affirm this, and as a substitute of listening to this canard of epidemic denial, all you need to do is begin studying a little bit science, as a result of the reply may be very clear, and that is catastrophic for our nation.
Rosin: “Catastrophic,” he says, as a result of households proceed to endure, as a result of their little one won’t ever, as he put it, do most of the issues that make life price residing.
I’m Hanna Rosin. That is Radio Atlantic.
There may be loads of confusion on the market about autism—why it’s rising, if it’s even rising. And what even counts as autism? And I believe it’s truthful to say that RFK’s sturdy and public entry into this debate has not in any approach helped to clear issues up.
So we’re gonna discuss to somebody who writes about autism and in addition covers politics for the U.Okay. paper the Unbiased, and is himself autistic: Eric Garcia, creator of We’re Not Damaged: Altering the Autism Dialog.
Eric, welcome to the present.
Eric Garcia: Thanks.
Rosin: Eric, you coated that April 16 press convention that RFK held about autism. Was there something in his assertion that caught out to you?
Garcia: Yeah, you already know, there was clearly the entire thing, which is that “autism destroys households.”
RFK Jr.: That is a person tragedy as properly. Autism destroys households, and extra importantly, it destroys our best useful resource, which is our youngsters.
Garcia: Saying that autism destroys kids or destroys households is so corrosive, and it goes into the bigger stereotype that individuals with disabilities are a burden.
RFK Jr.: These are children who won’t ever pay taxes. They’ll by no means maintain a job. They’ll by no means play baseball. They’ll by no means write a poem. They’ll by no means exit on a date. A lot of them won’t ever use a bathroom unassisted.
Garcia: I hear him taking a number of the most intimate and graphic particulars of autistic folks’s lives and utilizing it as a pawn for spreading disinformation.
RFK Jr.: These are kids who shouldn’t be—who shouldn’t be struggling like this. These are children who, a lot of them have been absolutely practical and regressed due to some environmental publicity into autism once they’re 2 years previous. And we have now to acknowledge we’re doing this to our youngsters.
Garcia: And I see him additionally taking the actual challenges that high-support-needs folks [have] and making their lives seem to be a tragedy quite than lives which can be entire and worthy on their very own. This isn’t to say that they don’t face important challenges. They completely do, however exploiting their experiences in such a public approach, in some methods, virtually bordered on pornography to me.
Rosin: I wish to get into RFK’s precise concepts about autism. Let’s begin with the concept there’s an autism epidemic. That is one thing he’s been saying for many years. It’s a vital a part of his argument. It’s the idea from which every little thing else flows: There may be an epidemic, so we have now to get to the basis of it and do one thing about it. So I’m going to do one thing that’s not that podcast pleasant, which is take a look at what anyone listening to this podcast might do, which is Google the time period improve in autism diagnoses, improve in autism, and also you’ll see—are you able to describe what you’re taking a look at?
Garcia: Yeah, it’s identified type of, like, because the hockey stick.
Rosin: Yeah.
Garcia: What you see is that over time, there was a rise in diagnoses. So it says that one thing like one in 10,000 children up to now had an autism prognosis. After which over time, that quantity simply will increase and will increase, and it makes it appear like, on a really floor stage with a really surface-level understanding, that that is an epidemic.
Rosin: Proper. And I wish to pause right here as a result of I really feel like that is very complicated to folks. Anyone can Google these charts, and just about any 12 months you begin in—so there’s a chart that exhibits California. You can begin within the ’40s and ’50s. Principally, no one has autism.
Garcia: Right.
After which it’s across the 12 months 1990 when it begins to carry. And then you definitely get to 2020, and it booms into the sky. Now, you are able to do this about Northern Eire, California, Sweden—
Garcia: Oman, China.
Rosin: —Oman, China. I imply, mainly all people would take a look at these charts and listen to RFK say there’s an autism epidemic, and it makes some type of sense. And I believe it’s actually essential to pause right here as a result of that’s what a layperson who is aware of nothing would choose up.
Garcia: It completely is smart that on the floor it seems to be like there’s this spike. However you need to keep in mind, after all, autism didn’t get a separate prognosis within the Diagnostic and Statistical Handbook of Psychological Issues till 1980. It didn’t get one. Then you definately received what was then referred to as Asperger’s syndrome, because of the analysis of Lorna Wing in the UK. Then in 1994, which was the 12 months that my dad and mom began screening me for issues, you bought I imagine it was PDD-NOS, pervasive developmental dysfunction not in any other case specified. However, you already know, it was this gradual enchancment in and broadening of the spectrum. After which in 2013, what occurred is the American Psychiatric Affiliation, which publishes the DSM, places all of those diagnoses below one umbrella as autism spectrum dysfunction, and there are ranges.
There’s Degree 1 autism, which is individuals who can communicate in full sentences however may need problem with sensory processing or may need problem with social interplay. Then there’s Degree 2, the place they may be capable to communicate in smaller sentences or smaller phrases. After which there’s Degree 3, which is the place they want, you already know, I believe, the traditional around-the-clock care that we sometimes related to autism—and we nonetheless affiliate with autism. And we shouldn’t erase these folks. However I believe that it’s essential to do not forget that the diagnostic standards was altering on the time.
Rosin: Proper, so all this broadening of the diagnostic standards, all of the stuff you’re describing, that explains loads of the sudden rise, what RFK is asking “the epidemic.”
Garcia: Sure. This was across the time that individuals with disabilities acquired extra rights. The [Americans with Disabilities Act] was handed in 1990. And it’s essential to do not forget that though autism wasn’t actually talked about within the ADA, it was talked about particularly within the People with Disabilities Schooling Act, and that simply meant that you simply noticed a rise within the variety of kids being served who had what we now take into account autism spectrum dysfunction.
So it’s type of this unusual marriage of the science bettering and authorities coverage inflicting a windfall. So it was straightforward, I believe, for folks to take a look at these numbers and say epidemic.
Rosin: Proper. And the plain query is why? Now, RFK appears fairly sure about what the trigger is.
RFK Jr.: Inside three weeks—and doubtless, we’re hoping, in two weeks—we’re going to announce a collection of recent research to establish exactly what the environmental toxins are which can be inflicting it. This has not been performed earlier than, and we’re going to do it in an intensive and complete approach, and we’re going to get again with a solution to the American folks very, in a short time.
Rosin: By the way in which, Eric, it’s been, like, two or three weeks, and that report by no means got here out, no less than not but. However the essential phrase to me in that’s “exactly what environmental toxins are inflicting it,” not if environmental toxins are inflicting it however which of them. So what does he imply by that? He’s mainly concluded, regardless of this openness he has to doing analysis, that the reason for autism is environmental toxins. What’s he referring to?
Garcia: That is one thing that’s been talked about for a very long time, which is that environmental toxins have contributed, if not play a significant function, within the improve in autism charges.
After which the opposite main offender is, after all, vaccinations, and significantly the MMR vaccination—the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine. And that has been debunked a number of occasions. The man who put out that research, Andrew Wakefield, had his medical license revoked in the UK, and the research that was put out in 1998 was retracted in 2010.
Rosin: Proper. So we have now pinned down what RFK believes: That is an environmental toxin. Let’s get to the basis of it.
Garcia: Right.
Rosin: That’s his perception, and he occurs to be the secretary of the HHS, so his perception holds some weight proper now. Now let’s shift from what he believes to what the scientific consensus and the world is saying, versus what RFK is saying. When have been you born?
Garcia: I used to be born in 1990.
Rosin: 1990. Okay. That’s a vital 12 months as a result of it’s across the interval that everybody pinpoints to when autism begins to blow up. What’s your expertise as a baby, rising little one of how persons are speaking about autism?
Garcia: That is actually attention-grabbing. It’s humorous, the way in which that my mother says it’s that—so we have been residing in Wisconsin on the time, and he or she learn this advert on the paper for, like, free pre-Okay screenings. That is, like, in 1994 or ’95. They couldn’t pinpoint, however they mentioned there was one thing “fallacious” with me or there was one thing—like I wasn’t hitting the marks.
However you need to keep in mind, after all: There’s at all times a lag in scientific understanding, like, when one thing is established, you already know, formally versus when it enters our bloodstream, so to talk, or enters the zeitgeist.
In order that they didn’t know, however they have been like, Properly, he’s verbal. He might communicate, so we don’t know if that’s autism, and issues like that. After which what occurred was we moved to Sacramento, and what occurred, based on my mother, is that she’s making an attempt to get companies, issues like that. They are saying, He’s superb. There’s nothing fallacious with him. It’s bizarre—like, in Wisconsin, they’re like, One thing’s, quote, unquote, “fallacious.” After which in California it’s, There’s, quote, unquote, “nothing fallacious with him.”
After which it simply so occurs that my dad’s boss’s spouse occurred to be the top of, like, particular schooling for your complete area. In order that received me, like, an in. After which what occurred is afterward, we moved to San Antonio, Texas, and there was this one physician who, I assume, had been researching autism for some time. After which they have been like, Properly, that is what it’s referred to as—this Asperger’s syndrome.
After which, like, I began—and it’s humorous as a result of, you already know, whenever you hear this time period Asperger’s syndrome, it’s like you may think about the type of jokes which can be made on the playground on the time. And, you already know, it was humorous as a result of my diagnostic journey type of matched the science and the general public understanding because it was coming.
[Music]
Rosin: So the scientific consensus and Eric’s life appear to indicate {that a} main cause autism is, quote, “on the rise” is due to improved consciousness and entry to well being care. However inside the autism neighborhood, there’s a lot much less consensus about what RFK is saying and what needs to be performed subsequent. That’s after the break.
[Break]
Rosin: RFK is just not the one individual, although, who believes that this isn’t nearly diagnoses.
Garcia: Right.
Rosin: Proper. So there are professional scientists who would say, Oh, it’s not only a matter of: We’re capturing extra folks. There’s something occurring. So I wish to speak about that for a minute. Even RFK agrees that autism has a genetic element. Like, research of similar twins have proven that they’re extra more likely to each be autistic. What different elements have folks discovered have contributed to autism because the Nineteen Nineties?
Garcia: Yeah. There have been talks about how, like, you already know, dad and mom having kids older is—
Rosin: Proper, the age of fathers.
Garcia: The age of fathers is likely one of the issues. There’s speak about mutated sperm. , so there undoubtedly is a few dialogue. And, you already know, and I ought to be aware that the USA spends a lot cash on researching autism, and a big chunk of the tasks the USA authorities and nonprofits fund are about biology.
Rosin: So what, in your thoughts, is the issue with RFK calling it an epidemic?
Garcia: The issue with RFK calling it an epidemic, for my part, is that it treats it prefer it’s a disaster. It treats it as if it’s one thing to be mounted or it’s one thing to be mitigated and one thing to be stopped. And once we already spend a lot time researching the biology and researching—and I’m not essentially even against researching biology. I believe it might be worthwhile. I believe it might result in scientific breakthroughs. It might assist with discovering methods to deal with co-occurring situations, like epilepsy. A variety of autistic folks die from epileptic seizures.
However, like, treating it as a disaster and treating it as one thing to be mounted or prevented is corrosive to loads of households. It’s corrosive to loads of autistic folks. It places the blame again on dad and mom, and it focuses extra on fixing this concern quite than accommodating and giving companies to autistic folks when the pie is so scarce. , this is similar administration that’s making an attempt to chop Medicaid.
Rosin: Proper. So when you find yourself standing and listening to RFK say issues like this, to you, the message is, One thing about me must be mounted.
Garcia: Sure. And one thing about a considerable amount of folks must be mounted, quite than, These are people who find themselves human beings who want companies and who want assist and who want acceptance on this planet.
Rosin: I wish to speak about how RFK’s statements have opened up and uncovered sure rifts contained in the world of autism. Not too long ago, a mom of an autistic little one, Emily Might, wrote an op-ed in The New York Occasions, which was referred to as “Kennedy Described My Daughter’s Actuality.”
She writes, “When [Robert F. Kennedy] Jr. mentioned in a current press briefing,” the identical one we’ve been speaking about, “that autistic kids will ‘by no means pay taxes,’ ‘by no means maintain a job,’ ‘by no means play baseball,’ many individuals within the autism neighborhood reacted angrily.” In all probability you probably did, Eric. “And but I used to be transported again to the psychiatrist’s workplace and her bleak prognosis that my little one may by no means communicate once more. I discovered myself nodding alongside as Mr. Kennedy spoke concerning the grim realities of profound autism.”
Are you able to clarify what this divide is about between, say, a neighborhood that you simply signify and this mother or father’s neighborhood of youngsters who she describes as profoundly autistic?
Garcia: Yeah. First off, I ought to say, and I wish to be as cautious as I can with this—I don’t wish to make too many individuals mad. It’s essential to do not forget that loads of dad and mom of high-support-needs autistic children disagree with Emily, and lots of people agree along with her. The truth is, Emily and I have been DMing earlier than that article got here out. And, you already know, the factor that I might say is that time period, “profound autism,” that’s an ongoing debate that’s occurring proper now as a result of The Lancet in 2021, 2022 put out a fee arguing that there wanted to be a separate label referred to as “profound autism” for these type of, as I discussed, Degree 3 autistic folks or what we might name excessive assist wants. And their argument is that the prognosis of the spectrum is just too broad, and that creating the 2013 prognosis of ASD erases the wants of some folks, of these high-support-needs folks, and folk like myself are occupying the dialog.
Rosin: Is that as a result of you may communicate for your self, whereas a nonspeaking little one can’t essentially communicate for themselves?
Garcia: Yeah, that’s their argument.
Rosin: And they also really feel like they’ve been made invisible now?
Garcia: They really feel like they’ve been made invisible, and I believe that they really feel like, whereas we’ve been highlighting loads of the accomplishments of individuals like myself, that we’re ignoring their wants. And so there’s this concept that there’s a must create a separate label, profound autism, and loads of autistic self-advocates, together with some nonspeaking autistic self-advocates, argue that that is that this is able to simply add to stigma—and that by labeling somebody as profoundly autistic, that will decrease expectations and say that they’d by no means be capable to obtain all these issues.
And the factor that I might say is that loads of occasions, my overture—I’m not an activist; I’m a journalist; I’m a author; I write about autism, however I don’t advocate for a coverage factor, however my overture—and my olive department and my fig leaf is the people who find themselves on the entrance strains, advocating to your children, are those self same talking autistic advocates and those self same self-advocates.
It’s humorous—once I was interviewing Julia Bascom, the previous head of the Autistic Self Advocacy Community, she has in her workplace one of many indicators that they made for pushing again in opposition to the repeal of Obamacare, saying, “Please don’t lower Medicaid so autistic folks must cease making telephone calls.”
They’re on the entrance strains this time to stop the cuts to Medicaid that Republicans wish to do, that RFK’s administration—the Trump administration—desires to do, and Home Speaker Mike Johnson desires to do, and Republicans within the Home wish to do.
Rosin: I see. So that you’re saying you, as a talking autistic advocate or author, do not make a distinction between excessive wants and not-high wants. You’re simply on the market elevating consciousness for autism extra broadly, whether or not it’s for her child, for your self, for society simply to typically perceive autism.
Garcia: And I’ll say this, and I imply this from the underside of my coronary heart, and forgive me for being—I don’t know the way emotional I might be on this factor.
Rosin: As a lot as you need.
Garcia: Yeah. I believe assembly different autistic folks, together with high-support-needs, nonspeaking autistic folks, helped me find out about myself. , I take into consideration how when nonspeaking autistic folks for thus lengthy—they’re diminished, and their voices are erased, and other people write them off as undeserving or not legitimate. I’m reminded of once I was referred to as a retard in elementary faculty.
And so what I might say to them is that, like, I don’t know what it’s prefer to be nonspeaking autistic, however I do know what it’s prefer to be overwhelmed and overstimulated in a world that doesn’t—you already know, I didn’t drive a automotive to get right here, as a result of I can’t drive.
Some autistic folks can drive, and God bless them. I simply can’t. It’s overwhelming—sensory overload. And I assume what I simply wish to say is that I don’t know precisely what it’s like, however I’ve realized a lot out of your children. I’ve realized a lot, and I’ve realized how related we’re. And I’ve realized how, though there are nonetheless very massive variations, that they should be handled [as] legitimate. And if I fought so arduous to get my voice heard, my God, the explanation why I attempt to interview nonspeaking—it’s so essential in all of my books and all of my writing to incorporate nonspeaking voices, as a result of, my God, I would like their tales advised and I would like them to be heard.
Rosin: Isn’t that what RFK desires? Like, what’s fallacious together with his strategy to nonspeaking autistic children? Like, his bringing this to gentle? What’s the distinction between what you need and what he desires?
Garcia: I believe what I would like is, I believe the distinction—as a result of, imagine it or not, there may be some overlap—is that he sees this as a tragedy to be mounted. I see these as individuals who deserve every little thing attainable. We’re in all probability at all times going to have autism, and we’re at all times going to have autistic folks with us.
So what will we do about it? How will we serve these folks? How will we see them as full human beings who’ve wants and desires and considerations, and the way will we repair the gaps in order that the really impairing and disabling elements of autism are addressed and mitigated? And the way will we assist them to dwell good and completely satisfied lives?
Rosin: Properly, Eric, I really feel like that could be a lovely place to finish. I actually recognize you coming and speaking to me about this.
Garcia: Hanna, I actually recognize you having me right here. Thanks.
[Music]
Rosin: This episode of Radio Atlantic was produced by Rosie Hughes and Jinae West. It was edited by Claudine Ebeid. We had engineering assist from Rob Smierciak, fact-checking by Yvonne Kim. Claudine Ebeid is the chief producer of Atlantic Audio, and Andrea Valdez is our managing editor.
Listeners, in the event you like what you hear on Radio Atlantic, you may assist our work and the work of all Atlantic journalists whenever you subscribe to The Atlantic at theatlantic.com/listener. I’m Hanna Rosin, and thanks for being a listener. Speak to you subsequent week.
This text initially misstated the date of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s press convention as July 16, quite than April 16.
